The Last Five Years, a musical concert celebrating its 25th anniversary, offers a unique perspective on love and time through the lens of a curdled marriage. This production, starring Rachel Zegler and Ben Platt, presents a fascinating take on relationships and the passage of time.
What makes this musical stand out is its innovative narrative structure. The story unfolds through the perspectives of a couple, Jamie and Cathy, with one character charting the story in reverse, post-breakup, while the other progresses chronologically from the initial infatuation. This masterstroke creates a captivating contrast and a unique exploration of a relationship's arc.
The Power of Absence
One of the most striking aspects is the emphasis on absences. Zegler, as Cathy, masterfully portrays the frustration of a partner's unfinished business, their voice going unheard by a departed ex. This theme of absence is accentuated throughout the semi-staged production, adding a layer of emotional depth.
Cultural and Personal Dynamics
Platt's portrayal of Jamie, a novelist, brings to life the cultural and personal dynamics within the relationship. His solo, "Shiksa Goddess," humorously captures the anticipation of a Jewish family's reaction to his passion for a gentile partner. Zegler's sardonic humor and fixed grin during "See I'm Smiling" add a layer of complexity to Cathy's character, showcasing her resilience and inner strength.
The Toll of Success and Rejection
As the story progresses, Brown makes acute observations about the impact of success and rejection on a relationship. Jamie's meteoric rise and Cathy's stalling career create a dynamic where one partner is shut out from the other's success. This theme is explored through Cathy's spiraling interior monologue during her audition, highlighting the toll of professional rejection.
Time and Artistic Pursuit
The musical's understanding of time is profound. It measures moments critically, from ambling evenings to late arrivals and early departures. The concept of "Jamie-land," where Cathy observes Jamie's artistic pursuit, adds a layer of introspection. The talking clock and Platt's performance of "The Schmuel Song" further emphasize the passage of time and the fleeting nature of youth.
A Jumble of Emotions
The format, akin to a memory play, creates a whirlwind of emotions. Joy and pain intertwine over a swift 90 minutes, even in the most mournful moments. The band's music, ranging from rollicking piano to pop-cabaret fizz, adds a sparkle of romance, while Zegler's high-kicking number with a cuddly toy brings a touch of whimsy.
The Bond Between Actors
Despite the characters' limited time together on stage, Platt and Zegler manage to convey a convincing bond. Their individual performances leave an impression of sadness, not just for the end of their relationship, but for the individual losses and missed opportunities.
A Transformative Experience
The casting of musical theater megastars like Zegler and Platt adds a layer of allure to the production. Their performances, especially Zegler's convincing portrayal of a character growing younger, and Platt's loss of initial lightness, transform the stage. The sold-out show, without a press night, speaks to the power of their talent and the allure of this unique musical.
In my opinion, The Last Five Years is a thought-provoking and emotionally charged musical. It offers a fresh perspective on love, time, and the complexities of relationships. The innovative narrative structure, coupled with powerful performances, makes it a must-see for theater enthusiasts and anyone seeking a deeper understanding of the human experience.
